Bay Cities and Water Politics
The Battle for Resources in Boston and Oakland
Sarah S. Elkind
Winner: Abel Wolman Award
Near the end of the nineteenth century, the cities of Boston and Oakland each faced environmental crises of water contamination and shortages that existing regional agencies could not solve. How these two cities resolved their water problems is the basis of a comparative history that provides valuable insights into urban development and explores the political implications and environmental impacts of regionalism.
“Individuals with an interest in urban planning, urban growth, political reform, and water management will benefit greatly from this book.”
“This study is important because it brings the perspectives of two neglected disciplines—environmental history and the history of public works—to the larger story of the rise of American cities. . . . the best kind of western history: tight and local, but enlivened by comparative perspectives.”
—Western Historical QuarterlySee all reviews...
“Elkind’s study is useful as a contribution to environmental history. But it is more than simply that; her book also will be valuable to urban and political historians, local historians of the Boston and Oakland areas, and urban planners.”
“An important book for historians and other scholars interested in urban politics or environmental issues.”
—Journal of American History
“Elkind has written an important book that brings new perspectives and examples to an important environmental issue.”
—American Historical Review
“Bay Cities and Water Politics is the rare historical study that speaks directly and intelligently to the policy implementation concerns of municipal managers and engineers.”
—Technology and Culture
“Bay Cities and Water Politics is part of a new generation of books concerning the urban environment that makes more understandable the administration of key sanitary services, the changing role of public authority, and the implications of metropolitan growth. An important addition to the literature, well worth a careful read.”
—Martin Melosi, author of Garbage in the Cities: Refuse, Reform and the Environment, 1880–1920
“Elkind skillfully weaves together environmental, political, and urban history. By comparing water supply and sewage disposal systems in Boston and Oakland, she provides excellent case studies of the evolution of special districts and regionalism in the United States. An important book that will appeal to a wide range of readers, including historians, political scientists, and urban planners.”
—Donald J. Pisani, author of Water, Land, and Law in the West
“An insightful and powerful critique of the role of regional governments in Boston and Oakland. Elkind’s penetrating analysis clearly demonstrates the long-term political and environmental costs of these Progressive Period reforms.”
—Joel Tarr, author of The Search for the Ultimate Sink: Urban Pollution in Historical PerspectiveSee fewer reviews...
Water defined the limits to growth of these bay cities and, as Sarah Elkind demonstrates, water supply and sewage disposal were two aspects of a single problem. Each city opted to abandon municipal water and sewer networks for metropolitan systems that crossed county lines and were administered by regional agencies. These agencies increased the cities' access to water resources, but, as Elkind shows, urban expansion and adoption of regionalism also decreased voter control over utilities and policies, and spread the environmental costs of urbanization far beyond city limits.
Combining insights from urban, western, and environmental history, Elkind examines the ways that people's reactions to their natural surroundings drive both demand for improved public services and political reform. She traces public works development in the Gilded Age and Progressive Era to explain how these programs united each city with its suburban neighbors, creating new political entities and allowing Boston and Oakland to appropriate rural resources and thus overcome the environmental limits to their continued growth and prosperity. She also shows how, when the power of regionalism is turned to urban development, environmental and social costs are sometimes overlooked.
Bay Cities and Water Politics provides a comprehensive view of the transformation of cities, their natural surroundings, and their politics. Elkind applies urban history to environmental concerns, as well as environmental history to urban problems and human needs. The book offers new insights into the importance of metropolitan special districts and their role in urban expansion, and it sounds a warning regarding the ability of regional water systems to maintain a balance between continued urban growth and delicate ecosystems.