Electing the House
The Adoption and Performance of the U.S. Single-Member District Electoral System
Jay K. Dow
In the United States we elect members of the House of Representative from single-member districts: the candidate who receives the most votes from each geographically defined district wins a seat in the House. This system—so long in place that it seems perfectly natural—is, however, unusual. Most countries use proportional representation to elect their legislatures. Electing the House is the first book-length study to explore how the US came to adopt the single-member district system, how it solidified into a seemingly permanent fixture of American government and whether it performs well by the standards it was intended to achieve.
The US Constitution grants the states the authority to elect representatives in a manner of their own choosing, subject to restrictions that Congress might impose. Electing the House reminds us that in the nation’s early years the states exercised this privilege and elected their representatives using a variety of methods. Dow traces the general adoption of the present system to the Jacksonian Era—specifically to the major franchise expansion and voter mobilization of the time. The single-member district plurality-rule system was the Federalists’ solution to tyranny of the majority under the expectation of universal franchise, and the Jacksonian-WhigsEra response to the political uncertainty caused by large-scale voter mobilization. The system was solidified concurrently with the enfranchisement of women in the early twentieth century and African Americans in the Civil Rights Era. Dow persuasively argues that the single-member district system became the way that we elect our representatives because it fits especially well within the corpus of political thought that informs our collective understanding of good governance and it performs well by the standards it was meant to achieve, and these standards are still relevant today.
“Jay Dow employs skill, care, and a range of intellectual tools to masterfully explain how each member of the U.S. House of Representatives came to be selected by voters in unique districts. He makes a constructive and persuasive case that these single member districts are vital for the American experiment in republican government.”
—David Brian Robertson,author of The Original Compromise: What the Constitution’s Framers Were Really Thinking
“Electing the House addresses several important questions related to the creation, development, institutionalization, and consequences of single member districts (SMD). Jay Dow shows that this critical feature of the US electoral system is best understood through a historical developmental approach that includes a blend of Founding ideas, institutions, social and political changes, and strategic choices. The book contributes mightily to the American political development (APD) literature on Congress, debates over the vitality of the American electoral system, and congressional reform.”
—Daniel Palazzolo, professor of political science, University of RichmondSee all reviews...
“This spirited defense of single-member districts (SMD) in the U.S. House reminds us “there is no perfect way of electing a representative assembly.” Grounded in the central debates of American political development and normative democratic theory, Jay Dow carefully elucidates the tradeoffs across systems while arguing that SMDs provide a uniquely American balance between liberalism and republicanism.”
—David Canon, professor of political science, University of Wisconsin–MadisonSee fewer reviews...
Locating the development of single-member district system within the context of American political thought, Dow's study clarifies the workings and the significance of a critical electoral process in our time. In the process, the book informs and enhances our understanding of the evolution of the American political system.