Soldiering On in a Dying War
The True Story of the Firebase Pace Incidents and the Vietnam Drawdown
Sales Date: July 5, 2022
- Published: July 2022
- Published: June 2011
- Published: September 2019
By the autumn of 1971 a war-weary American public had endured a steady stream of bad news about the conduct of its soldiers in Vietnam. It included reports of fraggings, massacres, and cover-ups, mutinies, increased racial tensions, and soaring drug abuse.
Then six soldiers at Fire Support Base Pace, a besieged U.S. artillery outpost near the Cambodian border, balked at an order to conduct a nighttime ambush patrol. Four days later, twenty soldiers from a second unit objected to patrolling even in daylight. The sensation these events triggered in the media, along with calls for a congressional investigation, reinforced for the American public the image of a dysfunctional military on the edge of collapse. For a time Pace became the face of all that was wrong with American troops during the extended withdrawal from Vietnam.
William Shkurti, however, argues that the incidents at Firebase Pace have been misunderstood for four decades. Shkurti, who served as an artillery officer not far from Pace, uses declassified reports, first-person interviews, and other sources to reveal that these incidents were only temporary disputes involving veteran soldiers exercising common sense.
Shkurti also uses the Pace incidents to bring an entire war and our withdrawal from it into much sharper focus. He reevaluates the performance and motivation of U.S. ground troops and their commanders during this period, as well as that of their South Vietnamese allies and North Vietnamese adversaries; reassesses the media and its coverage of this phase of the war; and shows how some historians have helped foster misguided notions about what actually happened at Pace.
By taking a closer look at what we thought we knew, Shkurti persuasively demonstrates how combat units still in harm's way adapted to the challenges before them and soldiered on in a war everyone else wanted to be over. In doing so, he also suggests a context to better understand the challenges that may lie ahead in the drawdown of troops from Iraq and Afghanistan.
"Meticulous research and judicious use of primary sources ground this superb study. . . . Current policy-makers and military planners should read this book for its hard-learned lessons, poignantly conveyed."—Naval Institute Proceedings
"A good read and a valuable addition to the scholarship on the Vietnam War."—On Point
“This is more than just another Vietnam War story—it is a case study of the American drawdown. Shkurti has used his own experiences, as well as prodigious research, to explain this little-known but important slice of the war.”—Dale Andradé, author of America’s Last Vietnam Battle: Halting Hanoi’s 1972 Easter Offensive
“Uncompromisingly honest, free of cant, very reflective, and investigating every relevant factor, Shkurti dissects the late-war U.S. army in convincing detail. . . . A spectacular book.”—John Prados, author of Vietnam: The History of an Unwinnable War, 1945-1975
“Deserves a place on every reading list that deals with that war.”—William M. Hammond, author of Reporting Vietnam: Media and Military at War
List of Figures and Tables
List of Abbreviations
Part One: The Siege
1. Winding Down
2. Proud Americans
3. Sappers in the Wire
4. Bad Omen
5. Sky Troopers
6. ARNVs, BUFFS, and Other Friends
8. Confusion on the Ground
9. Welcome to Prime Time
10. Under New Management
11. Leave No One Behind
12. Whiskey and Kool-Aid
Part Two: The Soldiers
13. The Grunts
14. Artillery and Other Combat Support Troops
15. Beyond Pace
16. Soldiering On in MR I
17. REMFs, Fraggers, Dopers, Slackers and Other Losers
18. Follow Me
19. A Thousand Calley’s?
Part Three: The Press
20. Boyle vs. the Powers That Be
21. The Press and the White House
22. The Press and the M-Word
Part Four: The Bigger Picture
23. South Vietnamese Allies
24. North Vietnamese Allies
25. Vietnamese Verdun
26. Pace as History
27. Lessons Learned?
28. Conclusions: A Difficult End to a Long War
Appendix A: Order of Battle MR III—U.S. Forces, Fall 1971
Appendix B: Order of Battle MR III—North and South Vietnamese Forces
Appendix C: Inspector General’s Report, October 11, 1971
Appendix D: Fact Sheet, Fire Support Base Pace Incident, October 22, 1971
Appendix E: Letter from Senator Kennedy to SP4 Al Grana, October 18, 1971
Appendix F: Letter from MG Donnelly Bolton to SP4 John P. White
Appendix G: Valorous Unit Award for Extraordinary Heroism to the 2/32d Field Artillery and Attached Units, July 3, 1972