"As Cilella explores in this book, the common soldiers of the regiment offer a remarkable look at the ordeal of the conflict."—Army History
"A complex and very valuable work for anyone with an interest in the Civil War, the soldier’s experience of war, and the veteran."—New York Military Affairs Symposium
"One of the most detailed, scholarly treatments of a volunteer Civil War regiment ever produced. . . . A distinguished contribution to the regimental history shelf in particular and Civil War literature in general."—Blue & Gray Magazine
"A rich portrait of one of the war’s more celebrated regiments. . . . This is an important piece of scholarship that deserves the attention of any serious student of the American Civil War."*—Journal of Military History
"This is a veritable tour de force of lucid prose and primary source research that raises the bar significantly for future regimental histories. . . . The author mined the letters and diaries of over 120 of the regiment’s members in order to tell their tale. And what a story it is! . . . A first-rate work that should appeal to anyone with an interest in regimentals in general and New York units in particular. Highly recommended."—Civil War News
"This detailed and thoroughly researched tome is narrative history at its finest. . . . This monumental work is sure to be the standard reference on the 121st New York Infantry for the foreseeable future."—New York History
"One of the most complete Civil War regimental histories to come down the pike in quite some time. It is reminiscent of the turn of the century unit histories that were written by the veterans themselves in terms of size and scope. ... Cilella utilizes the letters, diaries, and memoirs of over one hundred and twenty officers and enlisted men from Otsego and Herkimer counties in upstate New York to tell the fascinating story of men at war; their thoughts and opinions on just about every subject that is germane to them, from local gossip to their reasons for fighting in the first place.... Cilella uses a good mix of narrative and contemporary sources to create a compelling story of the experiences of the common citizen soldier in the Civil War. This is a must read for anyone interested in the period."—The Past in Review
"Narrative history at its finest. . . . This monumental work is sure to be the standard history of the 121st New York Infantry for the foreseeable future."The Freeman’s Journal
"Few are the new regimental histories of the Civil War that go much beyond battlefield actions and the casualties list. Cilella presents this upstate New York units history from the men’s point of view, from recruitment to discharge and beyond. Using diaries and letters, we get not only the story of their extensive role in 25 engagements of the Civil War, but also the soldiers views of just about everything slavery, politics, family, the officers who led them, and their friends who served beside them expressed either around the campfire or in a letter. A throwback to the regimental histories compiled in the 19th century but with even more attention to the men on the ground, this is a very readable and informative volume; highly recommended."—Library Journal (starred review)
“This is an evocative, engaging, and often exciting portrait of a regiment that has been probed by historians before—but never with such a fine brew of deep scholarship and skillful writing, and never with such perception about not only military life, but also the political and social forces behind the lines. Salvatore Cilella has made a unique and highly readable contribution to Civil War literature.”—Harold Holzer, Co-chairman, U.S. Abraham Lincoln Bicentennial Commission
“In a powerful and moving narrative, Cilella examines the men who served in the 121st New York infantry, from their rural backgrounds through vigorous warfare. This well documented study also explores how the survivors, only one-fourth of those who joined up, lived after the war. This book not only takes its place among the best of regimental histories, it serves as a model for the kinds of studies needed to understand the transformation of a war to preserve the union to one committed to a new birth of freedom.”—Orville Vernon Burton, author of The Age of Lincoln
“Cilella provides a remarkably full account of the 121st’s soldiers and their circumstances as they enlist, train, march off, and experience three years of the Civil War. His research on their experiences and attitudes is impressive, even amazing. Well written, informative, and analytical, it’s everything an excellent regimental history should be. I strongly recommend it.”—Steven Woodworth, author of Nothing But Victory: The Army of the Tennessee, 1861–1865
“Cilella wonderfully captures the experience of the common man in the Civil War as represented by those who were part of the campaigns of New York’s 121st Infantry.”—D. Stephen Elliott, President and CEO, New York State Historical Association and The Farmers’ Museum
