The Union that Shaped the Confederacy
Robert Toombs and Alexander H. Stephens
Sales Date: April 24, 2001
296 Pages, 6.00 x 9.00 in
- Published: April 2001
Winner: Richard B. Harwell Award
One was a robust charmer given to fits of passion, whose physical appeal could captivate women as easily as cajole colleagues. The other was a frail, melancholy man of quiet intellect, whose ailments drove him eventually to alcohol and drug addiction. Born into different social classes, they were as opposite as men could be. Yet these sons of Georgia, Robert Toombs and Alexander H. Stephens, became fast friends and together changed the course of the South.
Writing with the style and authority that has made him one of our most popular historians of the Civil War, William C. Davis has written a biography of a friendship that captures the Confederacy in microcosm. He tells how Toombs and Stephens dominated the formation of the new nation and served as its vice president and secretary of state. After years of disillusionment, each abandoned participation in the government and left to its own fate a Confederacy that would not dance to their tune.
Davis traces this unlikely relationship from its early days in the Georgia legislature through the trials of secession and war, revealing how both men persevered during the war and developed a deep animosity for Jefferson Davis. He then chronicles their postwar lives up to the emotional moment when Toombs stood eulogizing his long-time friend at his funeral, just four months after Stephens was elected governor of the Georgia they had loved as much as one another.
Drawing extensively on primary sources, including Stephens’s voluminous letters and Toombs’ widely scattered papers, Davis tells how two men of different temperaments remained friends, out of step with all but a few and occasionally even with each other. He concentrates on their Confederate years, when the fraternity they shared had its greatest impact, to show how they embodied both the strengths and the weaknesses of the Confederacy.
While there are biographies of each man, none convey the significance—or the depth—of their friendship. Davis shows us how they loved the South as it once was, the Union as they thought it ought to have been, and the Confederacy of their dreams that never came to be. They lost all three, but through five decades of crisis, they never failed each other.
"Davis is one of the best and most prolific Civil War scholars in the nation. . . . His writing is graceful, his analysis is penetrating, his insights are thought-provoking, his grasp of human nature, with all its frailties and complexity, is firm. . . . This is a new type of biography. By focusing on the Toombs-Stephens friendship and not simply on the men themselves, Davis reminds us that individuals, no matter how powerful or self-reliant, are not islands and do not exist in a vacuum. Like Joseph Ellis has done for the Revolution, Davis has opened a new direction for historians, who are beginning to look at the bond between Sherman and Grant, for instance, as well as that between Lincoln and Seward."—Georgia Historical Quarterly
"Davis’s books are always a pleasure to read, and this book is no exception. It is also insightful, accurate, and innovative. Those interested in the Civil War, indeed nineteenth-century America, need to know more about the role of social connections and friendships in politics and government, and this book is a strong contribution toward that goal."—Louisiana History
"Davis provides a dazzling overview of the entire era of the Confederate experience through the lives of two of its founders, Robert Toombs and Alexander Stephens. Davis skillfully traces the public lives and personal friendships of these two giants of Georgia politics and offers them as metaphors for their short-lived country, persuasively arguing that both represented forces of construction and of destruction in Southern politics, before, during, and after the Civil War. . . . Fresh, thoughtful, and riveting."—Civil War History
"This book is one of those little gems that tells and intriguing story and offers a multitude of small insights into the personalities of its subjects and their times. A pleasure to read."—American Historical Review
"A sympathetic but also sharply critical treatment of how two deeply flawed southern politicians both helped create and destroy the Confederacy. . . . Brings back excitement to the political history of the Civil War."—George Rable, author of The Confederate Republic
"In this engaging narrative, Davis offers compelling portraits of the two men, describes their critical roles in Confederate history, and illuminates the process by which their friendship thrived amid increasingly difficult political circumstances."—Gary W. Gallagher, author of The Confederate War
"A marvelous book that reads like a novel."—Emory M. Thomas, author of Robert E. Lee: A Biography
1. Disunion and Reunion
2. The Making of a Friendship
3. The Breaking of a Friendship
4. Founding Fathers
6. Loyal Opposition?
7. Enemies Front and Rear
8. Uncivil War
9. Exultations, Agonies, and Love