The Unitary Executive Theory
A Danger to Constitutional Government
Jeffrey P. Crouch, Mark J. Rozell, and Mitchel A. Sollenberger
“I have an Article II,” Donald Trump has announced, citing the US Constitution, “where I have the right to do whatever I want as president.” Though this statement would have come as a shock to the framers of the Constitution, it fairly sums up the essence of “the unitary executive theory.” This theory, which emerged during the Reagan administration and gathered strength with every subsequent presidency, counters the system of checks and balances that constrains a presidents executive impulses. It also, the authors of this book contend, counters the letter and spirit of the Constitution.
In their account of the rise of unitary executive theory over the last several decades, the authors refute the notion that this overweening view of executive power has been a common feature of the presidency from the beginning of the Republic. Rather, they show, it was invented under the Reagan Administration, got a boost during the George W. Bush administration, and has found its logical extension in the Trump administration. This critique of the unitary executive theory reveals it as a misguided model for understanding presidential powers. While its adherents argue that greater presidential power makes government more efficient, the results have shown otherwise. Dismantling the myth that presidents enjoy unchecked plenary powers, the authors advocate for principles of separation of powers—of checks and balances—that honor the Constitution and support the republican government its framers envisioned.
“Crouch, Rozell, and Sollenberger’s The Unitary Executive Theory is a timely and comprehensive look at what is perhaps the most crucial issue facing the American presidency—the true scope of presidential power in the age of Trump. Through well-documented examples in recent decades of how presidents have expanded their powers beyond what is stated and implied within the US Constitution, the authors show how relying on the unitary executive theory endangers the core framework of separation of powers and checks and balances provided by the framers. For anyone looking for a clear explanation of how we got to this place in American political history regarding presidential powers, this book is essential reading.”
—Lori Cox Han, author of Advising Nixon: The White House Memos of Patrick J. Buchanan
“This work by three of the nations leading political scientists is a must-read for all citizens concerned about the fate of the US Constitution. Crouch, Rozell, and Sollenberger’s dissection of the unitary executive theory is bolstered by an unparalleled wealth of knowledge of American political history and constitutional law. This pathbreaking work of scholarship could not be more timely—read it now before it is too late.”
—Stephen F. Knott, author ofThe Lost Soul of the American Presidency
“In their careful indictment of presidential claims to vast autonomy, Crouch, Rozell, and Sollenberger provide an invaluable primer on both the theory and practice of presidential power. In doing so they cover an impressive amount of ground across topics and time. They remind us that however loud and devout presidential ‘unitarians’ may be, the Constitution remains devoutly trinitarian.”
—Andrew Rudalevige, coauthor of The Obama Presidency: Appraisals and ProspectsSee fewer reviews...
A much-needed primer on presidential power, from the nation’s founding through Donald Trump’s impeachment, The Unitary Executive Theory: A Danger to Constitutional Government makes a robust and persuasive case for a return to our constitutional limits.