Battalion Commanders at War
U.S. Army Tactical Leadership in the Mediterranean Theater, 1942-1943
Steven Thomas Barry
Army Historical Foundation Distinguished Book Award
Most histories of the U.S. Army in World War II view the Mediterranean Theater of Operations primarily as a deadly training ground for very green forces, where lessons learned on the beaches of Oran, in the hills of the Kasserine Pass area, and at the collapse of the Tunis bridgehead all contributed to later success in Western Europe. Steven Barry, however, contends that victory in the MTO would not have materialized without the leadership of battalion-level commanders. They operated at a high level, despite the lack of combat experience for themselves and their troops, ineffective leadership at higher levels, and deficiencies in equipment, organization, and mobilization.
“The book has a place on the shelves of battalion commanders, future battalion commanders, and the leadership and staffs of professional military institutions. Barry reminds his readers that the preparation before combat—be it in a classroom or in the field—reaps rewards, saves lives, and helps produce victory.”
“. . .[A] solid contribution to the understanding of leadership challenges during the opening year of World War II.”
—H-Net ReviewsSee all reviews...
“Battalion Commanders at War is an important read for students of the U.S. Army, and not merely during World War II.”
—New York Military Affairs Symposium Review
“Barry is the first to look at battalion-level adaptation in conventional warfare. . . . An important contribution to the literature on the U.S. Army in World War II.”
—Douglas Porch, author of Path to Victory: The Mediterranean Theater in World War II
“Reverberates with the crack, boom, and rattle of combat. Essential reading for students of World War II and all aspiring military professionals.”
—Michael D. Doubler, author of Closing with the Enemy: How GIs Fought the War in Europe, 19441945
“A completely new and provocative interpretation of combat leadership in the American Army during World War II.—”
—Jonathan M. House, author of Combined Arms Warfare in the Twentieth CenturySee fewer reviews...
Barry portrays these officers as highly trained, adaptable, and courageous in their first combat experiences in North Africa and Sicily. Their leadership, he argues, brought discipline, maturity, experience, and the ability to translate common operational guidance into tactical reality, and thus contributed significantly to battlefield success in North Africa and Sicily in 1942-1943. To explain how this happened, he examines their prewar experiences, including professional military education and unit training exercises; personal factors such as calmness and physical resilience under fire; and the ability to draw upon doctrine, creatively apply the resources at their disposal, and clearly define and communicate mission goals and means. He also reveals how battalion leaders incorporated technological innovations into combined arms maneuvers by employing tank capabilities and close air support doctrine.
As Barry's assessment shows, these battalion commanders were not the sole reason for the Allied triumph in North Africa and Sicily, but victory would not have been possible without the special brand of military leadership they exhibited throughout those campaigns. Under their leadership, even inexperienced units were able to deliver credible combat performance, and without the regular army battalion leaders, U.S. units could not have functioned tactically early in the war.
One of the few studies to focus on tactical adaptation at the battalion level in conventional warfare, Barry's book attests to the pivotal value of professional military education-and makes an important contribution to today's "organizational learning" debate-while providing an in-depth view of adaptation of U.S. infantry and armored forces in 1942-1943.