Horace Mann's Troubling Legacy
The Education of Democratic Citizens
Bob Pepperman Taylor
A righteous reformer committed to the power of education, Horace Mann became a national figure by championing the common school movement. Mann's message, which he preached at every opportunity, was that universal public education was the only means to transform America's disorderly masses into a disciplined, judicious republican citizenry, thereby removing the dangers of anarchy and class warfare.
In his new look at Mann's work and thought, Bob Pepperman Taylor shows that Mann's ideas on civic education have had a lasting impact on the way that we still think today about education and its relation to our civic life. Written from the perspective of democratic theory and practice, Taylor's work reassesses Mann's philosophy of civic education and deeply resonates with today's pervasive and highly political debates about the role of education.
“Taylor gives us much to think about. His book is an engaging and provocative challenge to civic educators. . . . He leaves us thinking carefully about the theoretical foundations of our educational system and that system’s role in a democratic society.”
—Journal of American History
“This is a rich and thought-provoking work that is simultaneously challenging and accessible. Most important, it raises high-stakes questions about the relationship between education and democracy, questions that Mann himself would have been eager to talk about.”
—Journal of the Civil War EraSee all reviews...
“In a series of deftly structured comparisons, first, between Mann and J. S. Mill and, later, between John Dewey and Robert Hutchins, Taylor brings Mann’s legacy into current educational controversy.”
“Taylor has written an excellent, provocative analysis of Horace Mann’s ideas about civic education. Ironically, Mann’s particular approach to promoting democratic education actually may have threatened the very intellectual and moral development that he thought was essential for fostering American democracy. This thoughtful, highly original book will be of great interest to scholars and anyone interested in civic education today.”
—Maris Vinovskis, author of From a Nation at Risk to No Child Left Behind
“A first rate book presented in clear and compelling prose. Perhaps its greatest contribution is the compelling argument that Manns approach to school for civic education discounted and marginalized the role of schools in training the intellect, and that this anti-intellectual component has persisted in the current model of schooling in the U.S.”
—David F. Labaree, author of Education, Markets, and the Public GoodSee fewer reviews...
By conceiving of public schooling as serving primarily political ends, this nineteenth-century reformer fostered an enduring tension between educational values and political purposes. Taylor contends that Mann's approach to civic education marginalized the role of schools in training the intellect, and that this anti-intellectual component has been retained in the current model of schooling in the United States. He contends that Mann's schooling model promotes moral certainty and political consensus over intellectual doubt and political disagreement—an imbalance that erodes and weakens both educational and democratic ends.
By considering Mann's unique influence as a theorist of civic education, Taylor argues, we find both his greatest strengths and most significant weaknesses. And when we take Mann seriously as a contributor to American political thought, we find that the challenge he presents is more significant than concerns about the lack of originality or the unscientific nature of some of his ideas.
Ultimately, Mann can tell us a great deal about the very best in our educational tradition, as well as help us see some of its significant flaws and show us how both strengths and weaknesses have played out in our current public and higher systems of education. By examining how Mann was the first to articulate a cohesive vision of the relationship between civic education and democratic practice, Taylor demonstrates that Mann belongs among the key founders of the American political tradition.