A Nation of Laws
America's Imperfect Pursuit of Justice
Peter Charles Hoffer
America's founders extolled a nation of laws, for they knew that only a fairly enforced legal system could protect liberty and property against corruption and tyranny. Nearly two and a half centuries later, that system remains the ultimate safeguard for us all. With concise but penetrating and provocative insights, the eminent Peter Charles Hoffer recaptures the spirit of this grand enterprise while never losing sight of its human face.
The distillation of four decades of stellar writing, Hoffer's book is a wise and illuminating meditation on the key concepts, history, evolution, and importance of American law. He brings the law to life through brief narratives and portraits drawn from the pages of our nation's history. He takes his readers on a tumultuous journey from the Salem witchcraft trials through the divisive debates over slavery; the long struggles for equality and civil rights; the moral and culture wars over abortion, gay rights, and the teaching of evolution; and recent controversies concerning the rule of law in wartime.
“Interesting reading for those not already versed in the law. . . . Hoffer’s extensive bibliography will point the way for readers to pursue interests aroused by the author’s crash course in American legal history.”
“In this fascinating condensation of more than two centuries of American law into a slim 224 pages, Hoffer examines such criminal trials as those against abolitionist John Brown, feminist Susan B. Anthony, and evolution teacher John Scopes.”
—Steve Goddard’s History WireSee all reviews...
“The author of more than ten well-regarded texts on US legal history, Hoffer is extremely well qualified to prepare this current history of law in the US. Combining fine legal scholarship with colorful narratives and portraits taken from US history, Hoffer documents the development of law and legal institutions over a period of almost two and a half centuries. The book contains excellent footnotes, is extensively indexed, and is quite pleasurable to read.”
“Hoffer’s concise and fluent study of the history of American law packs a lifetime of learning into a fresh and challenging interpretation of the national experience itself.”
—Sean Wilentz, author of The Rise of American Democracy: Jefferson to Lincoln
“Beautifully written, this is the short book to read on American law—no one else has gotten it so right in so few words. Bravo!”
—Stanley N. Katz, editor of the Oxford International Encyclopedia of Legal History
“Brilliant and eclectic, short and highly readable. . . .A remarkable book.”
—Alfred L. Brophy, author of Reconstructing the Dreamland: The Tulsa Riot of 1921, Race, Reparations, ReconciliationSee fewer reviews...
In a very compact space, Hoffer has a great deal to say about the role of law, lawmakers, law cases, lawyers, litigants, judges, law professors, and public opinion in creating and recreating the fabric that weaves all of these elements together. He pays particular attention to the criminal trial by looking at the legal proceedings against slave liberator John Brown, feminist Susan B. Anthony, and teacher of evolution John Scopes. He also explores what happens when the law is stretched to the breaking point by revisiting such events as the Stono Slave Rebellion, the Seneca Falls women's rights convention, and FDR's paradigm-shifting New Deal speech.
Throughout, Hoffer carefully weighs the promise and vitality of our laws against its flaws and historical failures, for our legal system has not reflected a strong linear progress from inequality and privilege toward perfected liberty and dignity for all. His crystal clear vision of our legal history reminds us of the ambiguities and contradictions, quarrels and confrontations, that mirror the struggles within American history itself and reinforce the central role of law in American life.