How National Policy Shapes Community Action
Mara S. Sidney
Choice Outstanding Title
It is difficult to ignore the fact that, even as the United States becomes much more racially and ethnically diverse, our neighborhoods remain largely segregated. The 1968 Fair Housing Act and 1977 Community Reinvestment Act promised to end discrimination, yet for millions of Americans housing options remain far removed from the American Dream. Why do most neighborhoods in American cities continue to be racially divided?
“A strong contribution to the current debate on the failure of federal housing policies to solve the problem of poverty concentration in our cities.”
—Social Service Review
“Sidney’s book does a fine job of applying the policy design framework to analyzing outcomes of fair housing and community reinvestment legislation in the U.S., thereby greatly enhancing our understanding of the strengths and weaknesses of these two laws.”
—Housing StudiesSee all reviews...
“In this well-written book, Sidney skillfully utilizes the ‘policy design’ approach . . . to elucidate the relationship between national policy decisions and local political struggles surrounding the implementation of the Fair Housing Act of 1968 . . . . Sidney’s argument [is] quite clear, and the two case studies chosen are appropriate. The book’s clarity is further enhanced by her excellent writing style.”
—Perspectives on Politics
“An important contribution to our understanding of the politics of fair housing advocacy. Unfair Housing nicely illuminates the intersections of policy and politics in the fair housing advocacy arena.”
“This book makes significant contributions to housing equality research.”
—Perspectives on Political Science
“In a field where quick generalizations and easy typologies proliferate, Sidney presents solid new ideas. Highly recommended.”
“Sidney is simply brilliant in connecting the dots between national legislation, the funding mechanisms, the local advocacy strategies, the targets, and the impact of nonprofit advocacy work. An impressive and important book.”
—Peter Dreier, coauthor of Place Matters: Metropolitics for the Twenty-First Century
“A pathbreaking political analysis.”
—Gregory D. Squires, author of Capital and Communities in Black and White
“An important study that retraces the origins and aims of the two major federal policies—fair housing and community reinvestment—aimed at addressing racial segregation and discrimination in the housing market and mortgage lending industry.”
—Dennis Keating, coeditor of Revitalizing Urban NeighborhoodsSee fewer reviews...
The problem, suggests Mara Sidney, lies with the policies themselves. She contends that to understand why discrimination persists, we need to understand the political challenges faced by advocacy groups who implement them. In Unfair Housing she offers a new explanation for the persistent color lines in our cities by showing how weak national policy has silenced and splintered grassroots activists.
Sidney explains how political compromise among national lawmakers with divergent interests resulted in housing legislation that influenced how community activists defined discrimination, what actions they took, and which political relationships they cultivated. As a result, local governments became less likely to include housing discrimination on their agendas, existing laws went unenforced, and racial segregation continued.
A former undercover investigator for a fair housing advocacy group, Sidney takes readers into the neighborhoods of Minneapolis and Denver to show how federal housing policy actually works. She examines how these laws played out in these cities and reveals how they eroded activists capability to force more sweeping reform in housing policy.
Sidney also shows how activist groups can cultivate community resources to overcome these difficulties, looking across levels of government to analyze how national policies interact with local politics. In the first book to apply policy design theories of Anne Schneider and Helen Ingram to an empirical case, Sidney illuminates overlooked impacts of fair housing and community reinvestment policies and extends their theories to the study of local politics and nonprofit organizations.
Sidney argues forcefully that understanding the link between national policy and local groups sheds light on our failure to reduce discrimination and segregation. As battles over fair housing continue, her book helps us understand the shape of the battlefield and the prospects for victory.